About 3/5 of the audience liked the Barilla Plus (yellow box) the best. They commented that it had a nice texture and wasn’t overly ‘wheaty’ or ‘grainy’ but that it did have a slightly different taste from regular pasta which wouldn’t compromise the taste of sauces.
The rest of the audience liked the Ronzoni Smart Taste (which is my favorite of the 3 as well). It is the same color and texture as regular pasta, though it can be overcooked more easily then regular pasta can be. The people who did not like the Smart Taste, said that it was to soft, thus they must be true aldente pasta lovers!
No one (except 1 staff member) liked the Barilla White Fiber. They found to soft, mushy, and without texture. The White Fiber is the newest of the three products and it definitely has some tweaking to go before it becomes a consumer favorite. It easily breaks down in the pot and in your mouth, probably because the added fiber makes the shape of the pasta very delicate once it has started absorbing water, and the nature of granulated fiber (think Metamucil) is to absorb water and dissolve - not something that is super sexy for pasta.
Happy Cheesing!